Gavekal Capital: Strong Consumer Confidence Not Helping European Retailers

Friday, March 21, 2014

Strong Consumer Confidence Not Helping European Retailers

Preliminary results indicate that European consumer confidence rose more than anticipated, with the measure closing in on levels not seen since prior to the global financial crisis:

image

As we would expect, this bodes well for a continued recovery in household consumption in the Euro area and confirms stronger than expected retail sales data that was released earlier this month:

image
image

In contrast, stock performance of all of the Apparel, Accessories, & Luxury Goods companies in MSCI Europe has not been positive so far this year...

image

Since foreign sales accounts for more than 60% of total sales in all but two of this sub-industry's members, we are not surprised to see a disconnect between these stocks and sentiment in Europe. The underperformance is more likely the result of consistently negative revisions to sales and earnings estimates over the last 1-, 3-, and 6-month time periods:

image